Take Profit Trader shifts the trail mechanic as you move from Test → PRO → PRO+. Tradeify keeps the trail uniform but shifts the consistency rule depending on which program you signed up for. Same lifecycle-landmine pattern, opposite axis. Here's how they actually compare.
| Axis | Take Profit Trader | Tradeify |
|---|---|---|
| Lifecycle | 3 phases: Test → PRO → PRO+ | 3 parallel programs: Growth / Select / Lightning |
| Eval structure | 1-step Test, 5-day minimum | 1-step (Growth/Select), 1–3 day minimum; or instant-funded (Lightning) |
| Trail type | Shifts per phase: EOD → intraday → EOD | Uniform EOD across all programs |
| Lock archetype | Locks at Starting Balance (Topstep funded family) | Locks at SB + $100 (Apex 4.0 / MFFU family) |
| Consistency | 50% on Test only; drops on funded | Depends on program: Growth eval-free / funded 35%; Select eval 40% / funded-free; Lightning progressive 20→25→30% |
| Account sizes | 5 sizes: 25K / 50K / 75K / 100K / 150K | 4 sizes per program: 25K / 50K / 100K / 150K |
| Daily loss limit | None firmwide (removed January 2025) — trail is the only hard guardrail | Growth eval has DLL; Lightning has DLL on 50K+; Select has none |
| Activation fee | $130 one-time per account | $0 baseline; Select can pay $1,500 (daily payouts) or $4,000 (flex) |
| Profit split | 80/20 on PRO → 90/10 on PRO+ | 90/10 after first $15K profits on Simulated Funded; 80/20 on Elite Live |
| Payout cadence | Daily on PRO/PRO+ once buffer cleared (7-day minimum between payouts) | 5-day default; Select upgrades possible (daily/flex); 60-min processing |
| Platforms | NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Rithmic | Tradesea (Rithmic), Tradovate, WealthCharts — NO NinjaTrader / TradingView / MetaTrader |
| News trading | Banned on PRO/PRO+ — no trading 1 min before/during/after FOMC, NFP, CPI | Permitted — Tradeify explicitly allows news |
| Microscalping | No explicit floor | >50% of trades AND >50% of profit must come from positions held >10 seconds |
| Overnight holds | Banned — flat by 5 PM ET Mon–Fri | Banned — flat by 5 PM ET; also cannot hold through 5–6 PM ET maintenance window |
| Max funded accounts | 5 | 5 (total funded size capped at $1M) |
Deep dive → Daily loss limits and the 4-archetype taxonomy — DLL is the third axis the table quietly reveals, and this pair maps two of the four cluster archetypes in one comparison. TPT is firmwide-deleted (no DLL on any phase since January 2025) — the cleanest policy-level removal in the cluster. Tradeify is per-program-configured ($1,250–$2,500 on 100K, present on Growth eval + Lightning 50K+, absent on Select) — the only intra-firm 2-archetype split in the 2026 set. The cluster's other two archetypes round out the taxonomy: fork-locked-at-signup (Apex 4.0 EOD vs intraday, Bulenox Option 1 vs Option 2 — irreversible after buy) and platform-toggled (Topstep — present on NinjaTrader, absent on TopstepX — flippable by changing platforms). "Does this firm have a DLL?" is the wrong frame — ask which archetype, because that's what determines whether you can flip the answer after you've already bought.
The single most underrated quirk in any prop firm's rulebook is what changes between when you sign up and when you cash a payout. TPT and Tradeify both build a shift into the lifecycle — on totally different axes.
Test: EOD trail (drawdown floor only updates on the daily close). Pass the profit target, get auto-promoted to PRO. PRO: intraday trail (the floor advances on every new equity high during the session). Pass PRO and you're auto-promoted to PRO+ (since 2026-03-18). PRO+: back to EOD.
Growth: no consistency rule on eval — pass however you want — then 35% consistency on funded. Select: 40% consistency on eval — then no consistency rule on funded. Lightning: progressive 20% → 25% → 30% as you take payouts. The trail stays EOD across all three programs.
This matters because every shift is a place where a trader who learned one set of rules gets caught by the other. The two patterns target opposite types of trader:
Both firms use a "trailing drawdown that locks." The lock point is different and it materially changes the math.
Trail floor stops moving once equity exceeds (Starting Balance + Drawdown). E.g. 100K with $3,000 drawdown: floor advances until equity hits $103,000, then it freezes at $100,000. Same archetype as Topstep funded.
Trail floor stops moving once equity exceeds (Starting Balance + Drawdown + $100). E.g. 100K Growth with $3,500 drawdown: floor advances until equity hits $103,600, then it freezes at $100,100. Same archetype as Apex 4.0 / MFFU / Bulenox / Tradeify.
The $100 difference is not the point — the lock family is. TPT's funded ladder is structurally a Topstep cousin; Tradeify's is structurally an Apex cousin. That dictates which other rule patterns each firm tends to inherit (Tradeify's progressive Lightning consistency, for instance, is more Apex-shaped than Topstep-shaped).
Our free trailing-drawdown calculator presets TPT (lock at SB) and Tradeify (lock at SB + $100) side-by-side so you can see exactly when the floor freezes for your account size.
Open Trailing-Drawdown CalculatorIf you defaulted into one of these firms because of brand recognition, check the platform list before paying for an account.
NinjaTrader 8, Tradovate, TradingView, Rithmic. Most prop-firm-trader-default platforms covered.
Tradesea (Rithmic data feed), Tradovate, WealthCharts. NinjaTrader, TradingView, and MetaTrader are NOT supported.
Both firms' consistency rules land between 35–50% — numerically close, mechanically different.
| Phase / Program | TPT | Tradeify |
|---|---|---|
| Eval (entry phase) | 50% on Test (best-day ≤ 50% of total profit) | Growth: none · Select: 40% · Lightning: 20% on first payout (instant-funded, no eval) |
| Funded (post-pass) | None — drops on PRO / PRO+ | Growth: 35% · Select: none · Lightning: tightens to 25% → 30% |
| Direction across lifecycle | Tightens to None (you earn freedom) | Inverts (Growth gets stricter, Select gets looser, Lightning gets stricter) |
TPT is the simpler model: pass with a 50% best-day ceiling, then trade freely on funded. Tradeify forces a strategic choice at signup — do you want consistency-free eval (Growth) or consistency-free funded (Select)? Or instant capital with a tightening leash (Lightning)?
Deep dive → How consistency rules really work across the 2026 cluster — the wedge here is lifecycle direction, not threshold value. TPT's trajectory is tightens-to-none: 50% on Test, then drops entirely on PRO and PRO+. Tradeify's trajectory is program-determined inversion: Growth flips none→35% across eval→funded, Select flips 40%→none, Lightning monotonically tightens 20%→25%→30% across the first three payouts. No other pair in the cluster spans these two opposite trajectory shapes inside a single comparison. The cluster's other shapes round it out — Apex 4.0 is lifetime-flat (30% from PA purchase forever), MFFU Core is both-scope-flat (40% on eval AND funded), Bulenox is both-scope-flat at 40%, Earn2Trade GAU is eval-only-then-drops (30% on eval, none on funded). Pick by directionality first — "do I want my rule to relax over time, tighten, or invert?" — and threshold value second.
Our consistency calculator presets all three Tradeify programs and TPT's Test phase. Enter your phase total, see the max safe single-day P&L before a violation.
Open Consistency CalculatorActivation fee is $130 per account, paid up-front when you convert from Test to PRO. Payouts on PRO/PRO+ are daily once your buffer above starting balance is cleared (7-day minimum between payouts; 1–2 business day processing). Split steps up from 80/20 on PRO to 90/10 on PRO+ (auto-promoted).
No activation fee on the base programs. Payouts are 5-day cadence by default. Select offers two optional upgrades — $1,500 one-time for daily payouts, or $4,000 for "flex" payouts. 60-minute guaranteed processing. Split is 90/10 on Simulated Funded after the first $15K of profits, 80/20 on Elite Live.
If you intend to scale to multiple accounts, TPT's per-account activation adds up faster (e.g. 5 accounts = $650 in activation). Tradeify's $0 baseline is friendlier for multi-account stacking — but if you want daily payouts on Select, the $1,500 upgrade is a real cost. Lightning has no activation but charges more for the eval ($345–$796 range vs Growth's $99–$369).
Same eval-stage trader hits a single $1,200 winning day on a 50K account.
Identical session: equity spikes to +$2,800 intraday, gives back $1,400, closes at +$1,400 over the day. Account is 100K with the standard drawdown for each firm's program.
Aurafy tracks your trailing drawdown floor, consistency ratio, and per-firm rule state across all your accounts. Native screen recording. Free tier. No card required.
Try Aurafy free Browse free toolsYes — the two firms are independent. Both ban cross-account hedging within the same firm. Cross-firm hedging is not enforceable by either firm's rulebook (they can't see your other firm's positions), but it's still bad risk practice — do not coordinate equal-and-opposite positions between them.
No. Promotion from Test to PRO is automatic when you clear the profit target. The same applies to PRO → PRO+ since the 2026-03-18 auto-promotion change — TPT promotes accounts based on internal consistency / risk / execution review. You can't opt out of the intraday-trail PRO phase if you want to be funded with TPT.
You can't convert an existing account — but Tradeify allows up to 5 active funded accounts. You can run one Growth, one Select, and one Lightning in parallel and discover which program matches your trading style without losing the existing account. TPT's 5-account cap is the same.
Tradeify Lightning is instant-funded (no eval), so first-payout timing is gated only by the 5-day default cadence and the 20% first-payout consistency rule. TPT requires you to clear Test (5-day minimum) then start the PRO phase — daily payouts on PRO open as soon as the buffer above starting balance is cleared, with a 7-day minimum between payouts. Lightning wins on raw days-to-first-cash; TPT wins on lower upfront eval cost per dollar of funded capital.
Tradeify explicitly permits it. TPT bans news trading on PRO/PRO+ (no trading 1 minute before, during, or after FOMC, NFP, CPI). TPT Test has no news restriction. This is the single biggest behavioral-rule difference — if your edge relies on the open after CPI, Tradeify is the one to choose.
Both restrict pure HFT and copy-trading-across-your-own-accounts. Personal EAs that don't constitute HFT are tolerated case-by-case — the rulebook language is similar at both. Read each firm's current TOS before deploying a bot.
The rule states more than 50% of your trades AND more than 50% of your profit must come from positions held longer than 10 seconds. The target is sub-second scalpers and tick-arb strategies. Standard intraday scalping (~30 sec holds and up) is fine. TPT has no equivalent rule.
Aurafy auto-detects which trail mode applies to each account (intraday vs EOD) and tracks the lock point separately for the Topstep family (TPT) and the Apex family (Tradeify). The same journal works across all your prop-firm accounts and surfaces your consistency ratio live.
Aurafy is a futures journal built for prop traders. Multi-firm, multi-account, native screen recording, free tier with no card required.
Try Aurafy free Browse all prop-firm guides